Tiffiny
Tiffiny
Minneapolis, MN
Female
Single

China’s top dancer, paralyzed in a fall, thinks she’ll walk again. Is she delusional?

Posted: 5/14/2009 at 01:10 PM

  • share this:
  • Email to a Friend
  • Digg It!
  • StumbleUpon
  • Fark
  • Facebook
  • del.icio.us
  • Reddit
  • NewsVine

member(s) liked this post.

I read the news on CNN every morning. And today, a headline about Liu Yan caught my eye. She was (Some say she still is? That‘s strange) considered one of China’s top dancers, and she was scheduled to dance a number called the “Silk Road” at the opening ceremonies during the Beijing Summer Olympics last year.

But, as you probably heard by now, that never came to pass. Twelve days before the ceremony she fell during rehearsal, breaking her back, and has been unable to move anything from the waist down since. She’s technically a paraplegic, and as it goes with most spinal cord injuries, doctors don’t hold a sliver of hope that Liu will ever walk again.

And while this is tragic, it’s pretty much the truth (barring any miraculous cures for spinal cord injury that may be discovered in the semi-near future). But as I read the article, I realized Liu was adamant, determined in fact, that she WILL walk again. But is it wise to think this way? Will this only lead to disappointment, and in the end, further depression?

“Healthy dancers practice every day, I will do the same. This is how I am different from other patients -- I believe that I will recover when I do my exercise. I will live with hope,” she says in her interview with CNN.

One must wonder: Does she feel this way because the Chinese look down on people who accept their paralysis? Or is it because her injury is still so new she hasn’t come to terms with it yet? Or maybe….I’m the wrong one to be such a pessimist, and that maybe she really will walk again?

Whatever ends up happening, we’ll know in two years. That is when all possible healing that a body can do by itself to heal a damaged spinal cord will cease. After that, if she hasn’t gotten better on her own, she will not walk again on her own. She’ll have to wait for some kind of treatment to be developed.
Filed under: , ,
1,529 Views
  • share this:
  • Email to a Friend
  • Digg It!
  • StumbleUpon
  • Fark
  • Facebook
  • del.icio.us
  • Reddit
  • NewsVine

Your comment may take up to 15 minutes to appear.

Some HTML is allowed in the comments. See the list.
  • Tania wrote on May 14, 2009 at 2:07 PM
    If this attitude toward her paralysis is what she needs to get through life, who's to stop her? Perhaps such a positive attitude will help her in some way, regardless of whether she ever does walk again.
  • rainey826 wrote on May 14, 2009 at 2:52 PM
    I see nothing wrong with a positive attitude , yet it can also be setting her up for great disappointment in the end ! I am sure she is holding on to a dream for dancing was her life . Only time will tell . I wish the very best .
  • Kara wrote on May 14, 2009 at 6:13 PM
    Well unless she said it later in the article-she really stated that her exercises would help her "recover"...which by that definition-she's probably right. In many ways they will help her recover physically and I'm sure emotionally. I'm sure there are cultural factors but I'm so happy to hear that she's continuing to dance. She shouldn't lose her title because she's now a dancer with a disability
  • scipilot wrote on May 16, 2009 at 8:00 AM
    Giving up and making (or exepting the opion) that a person will never walk again is a very dangerous thing, I broke my neck C4/5 at the age of 16 and was told I would never walk and that I should be prepaired to live life from an electric wheelchair.

    I never acepted it and battled for 11 mnths in hospital until I was able to walk with cruches, no calipers etc
    br>The long and short of it was I walked for 30 years until needing to rely on a wheelchair.

    The day we give up hope is the day to lay down and die, I wish the dancer all the luck in the world and at the end of the day if she does not walk she will at least know in her heart that she tried.

    Robin
    DDA Access Audit Service
  • scipilot wrote on May 16, 2009 at 8:04 AM
    Giving up and making (or exepting the opion) that a person will never walk again is a very dangerous thing, I broke my neck C4/5 at the age of 16 and was told I would never walk and that I should be prepaired to live life from an electric wheelchair.

    I never acepted it and battled for 11 mnths in hospital until I was able to walk with cruches, no calipers etc
    br>The long and short of it was I walked for 30 years until needing to rely on a wheelchair.

    The day we give up hope is the day to lay down and die, I wish the dancer all the luck in the world and at the end of the day if she does not walk she will at least know in her heart that she tried.

    Robin
    DDA Access Audit Service
  • Nanal wrote on May 21, 2009 at 10:55 AM
    What a sad thing for her to have to deal with . I think, if she continues to hold out hope.......that there's some innervation left.........with determination, and effort.......who knows how far she can go. There have been, many, many instances where doctors have said to someone .......you'll never walk again........and.......they were dead wrong ! Who knows in this case......if that's true or not. She has my prayers and best wishes that she does dance again........never mind just walk ! Who knows ? God does !.............peace and love.......Norma
  • Kelly Narowski wrote on May 28, 2009 at 1:59 PM
    As everyone here probably already knows, there are complete and incomplete injuries. Last time I checked the stats, about 1/2 of spinal cord injuries end up being "incomplete," meaning there is little, some, or a lot of function below the vertebral level of injury. It's a huge spectrum. If she's a complete injury, she's not going to walk again, period. Well not until there's a cure or treatments to regenerate the spinal cord cells/tissue. Hard work doesn't reverse a complete injury. I hope she doesn't have a complete injury since some function is better than none. I have met many incomplete injured people who can walk (but have some paralysis and/or loss of sensation somewhere, to varying extents). I met a girl once who couldn't move anything below the C6 level but she had 100% sensation. Since there are 150 million nerves in the cord, no two injuries are the same. Since the cord is such a complex structure and we have so much to learn about it still, all the questions of her recovery can't be answered. One thing I hate though is when people say "I worked really hard and now I can walk." I am a T6 complete para and guess what- I worked hard in rehab too and still NOTHING moved, and there was nothing I could do about it. No amount of work or mental tricks was going to make my legs move. The nature of my spinal cord injury wouldn't allow it. I HOPE she "recovers" but it's unlikely. Of course she'll know a lot more at the two year mark. I do think most people when newly injured have to believe they are going to walk again. It's too much for the brain to process that they won't. To believe they will walk again without a doubt (and soon) is a coping mechanism. Whatever gets ya through the day. If you would have told me when I was first injured that I wouldn't ever walk again, I wouldn't have believed it or accepted it at all, it would have been "too much" to hear... so yes, she may be a little delusional, and that's ok. But I hope she's right!