Disabled Politico
Disabled Politico
NotSet
Single

Autistic Girl Scout labeled a "danger to others," removed from her troop

Posted: 11/25/2008 at 01:53 PM

  • share this:
  • Email to a Friend
  • Digg It!
  • StumbleUpon
  • Fark
  • Facebook
  • del.icio.us
  • Reddit
  • NewsVine

member(s) liked this post.

Magi Klages, a smiling young girl with long hair, steps off a bus.Magi Klages is eight years old and autistic, and she has been a Girl Scout for two years.  When the troop she was in was getting too large for her, her parents moved her to a smaller troop for disabled children.

 

She was kicked out on the first day for "causing a disturbance" when the children sat down for a group activity and Magi ran off, injuring herself.  Magi's mother, who was present at the troop meeting, argues that she never endangered anyone but herself and that her child's behavior is normal for her when confronted with unfamiliar situations.  The troop leader, who herself has a child with special needs, argues that Magi was scaring the four other girls, all of whom have physical disabilities.

 

Scouting claims a long tradition of tolerance.  The Girl Scout Law emphasizes that Scouts are to be "honest and fair," and the Klages family as well as many local autism advocacy groups argue that this decision is anything but.  They are currently searching for a new troop for their daughter.

 

Do you think it's worth having a segregated troop in the first place?  What kind of message will it teach children?

 

Related: Teacher Accused of Tying Autistic Kids to Chairs, Teacher Lets Students Vote Boy Being Diagnosed with Asperger's Syndrome out of Kindergarten Class

12,939 Views
  • share this:
  • Email to a Friend
  • Digg It!
  • StumbleUpon
  • Fark
  • Facebook
  • del.icio.us
  • Reddit
  • NewsVine

Your comment may take up to 15 minutes to appear.

Some HTML is allowed in the comments. See the list.
  • noahwfan wrote on Nov 25, 2008 at 6:05 PM
    When I was a kid, I was in Brownies, then Girl Scouts for years when I got older. However, I was in an integrated troop. I think segregating kids sends them the wrong message. Just because the girl has Autism doesn't mean she should be singled out because she has a disability. She should be in an integrated troop.
  • J Story wrote on Nov 26, 2008 at 4:19 PM
    Integration of people with autistic behaviours into the wider community will be a while yet, but is, I think, inevitable. Just as modern societies easily outpace Islamic backwaters that keep their women uneducated and unemployed -- effectively cutting GDP in half -- they will prosper who discover how to accommodate and employ the special skills and abilities that autistics offer. We must expect more -- both of our acceptance of autism, and also our expectations of what autistics can and cannot contribute. It is a modern tragedy that many are institutionalized or subjected to continual invasive "therapy" in the vain hope that they will become "normal". Formerly, left-handed people were forced "for their own good" to use their right hand, like everyone else. Now we know better.
  • Don Williams wrote on Nov 26, 2008 at 8:24 PM
    Mainstreaming is a wonderful concept. The execution leaves a lot to be desired. Having seen the results of these experiments in Northern Virginia, I remain dubious.
  • Dan wrote on Nov 26, 2008 at 9:13 PM
    Unless yer gay, or don't believe in God, then the Scouts don't want you.
  • Judy wrote on Nov 26, 2008 at 9:34 PM
    " I think segregating kids sends them the wrong message. Just because the girl has Autism doesn't mean she should be singled out because she has a disability. She should be in an integrated troop." I agree. According to the article, she already was in an integrated troop, then her parents took her out of that one and put her in a segregated troop, then the segregated troop's leader kicked her out: "...Magi Klages is eight years old and autistic, and she has been a Girl Scout for two years. When the troop she was in was getting too large for her, her parents moved her to a smaller troop for disabled children..." If only all these kids could be in the same troop instead of adults splitting them apart with stuff like "you ran away from my daughter" and "you're one kid too many for my daughter." "Unless yer gay, or don't believe in God, then the Scouts don't want you." Hey, those rules against gays and atheists are Boy Scouts of America rules. The Girl Scouts of America is a separate organization which doesn't have those rules.
  • Judy wrote on Nov 26, 2008 at 9:53 PM
    Meanwhile, since Klage's old troop didn't kick her out, if her parents change their mind she could return to that one. What if her old troop is one of those that has kids from different schools in it? Some of the other girls still in that troop might miss her because they don't still see her at school and welcome her back! Also, which would have been more difficult - adjusting to her old troop gaining some new and unfamiliar-at-first members or adjusting to another troop (which means every member would be unfamiliar at first!)? I don't know Klages so I can't say for sure.
  • Jim Jones wrote on Nov 26, 2008 at 10:50 PM
    Ahhh, she is so cute! how can anyone ban her, shame on them! www.anonymity.at.tc
  • name required wrote on Nov 27, 2008 at 12:21 AM
    what the he!! is wrong with these people? Oh yeah, I forgot, it's an organization of good will. Their own good will. Oh well, it's Thanksgiving. Maybe those responsible will have turkey infested with some non lethal, but extremely sickening, parasite.
  • Mkk wrote on Nov 27, 2008 at 12:26 AM
    My little sister is autistic, and I'm sick and tired of everyone treating them like they're animals that cannot be controlled. Asperger's is a high-functioning autism. They say this new group was for kids with physical disabilities...autism isn't physical. I was a girl scout, and I'm appalled at how these troops are treating this poor little girl. There should be no such thing as a segregated group. What the heck is wrong with this world?
  • Tricia wrote on Nov 27, 2008 at 12:47 AM
    Dan wrote on Nov 26, 2008 at 9:13 PM Unless yer gay, or don't believe in God, then the Scouts don't want you. Actually, Dan, that's just the Boy Scouts. While similar, Boy Scouts and Girl Scouts are two separate organizations (and always have been). The Girl Scouts do not require that its members believe in a god, and it does not have a policy banning lesbians from participating. However, it does specifically have a policy against discrimination of gay people, so there might be discrimination within certain councils.