Tiffiny
Tiffiny
Minneapolis, MN
Female
Single

Wheelchair/car hit-and-runs: Who’s to blame?

Posted: 12/11/2009 at 01:06 PM

  • share this:
  • Email to a Friend
  • Digg It!
  • StumbleUpon
  • Fark
  • Facebook
  • del.icio.us
  • Reddit
  • NewsVine

member(s) liked this post.

Hey wheelchair-users, if this mangled powerchair doesn’t scare you into being more vigilant when traversing crosswalks (and roads in general), I don’t know what will. This particular wheelchair was pushed more than 150 ft. before the driver fled the scene.

The hit-and-run occurred in St. Petersburg, Florida. Shirley Ann Lavine, 55, was crossing a MARKED crosswalk when some douchebag in a “light-colored, midsize vehicle” hit her, throwing her out, breaking several of her bones in the process. She is currently in critical condition.

This hit-and-run marks the third time in two weeks (in the Bay-area) that someone using a wheelchair was hit by a car. Is this a growing problem? Or are the people who drive in the Bay-area just really bad drivers? It also makes you wonder if the roads down there aren’t very well lit (?). Hard to say.

Whatever the case, this seems to be a growing problem in our nation, not just Florida (one look at Google News can prove that). We have more and more people using/getting approved for wheelchairs, and there are more cars on the roads than ever before. Not a good pairing.

Personally, I’ve never been hit - or even nicked - by a car during my years of wheelchair-travels. But I do know a guy who uses a scooter who was hit by a SUV while on a curb, waiting for the light to change. The behemoth SUV went up on the curb during its turn and nicked his chair. He was fine and his scooter was only scratched, but he was affected for months.

There’s got to be a way for cars and wheelchairs to co-exist safely. Some companies like SEE & BE SAFE have invented wheelchair-reflectors, which definitely helps. Maybe they need to start teaching “Watching Out For Wheelchairs 101” in Driver’s Training classes? I think bicyclists have this very same problem.

In the meantime, stay on the sidewalks and be cautious (i.e., NEVER assume cars see you). If you do this, you’ll at least decrease your chances of dying a miserable death on a lame city street somewhere.

What else is good? I refuse to put a flag on my chair.

- Are You Modeling Good Driving Behavior for Your Teen Driver?

- Emergency Preparedness: Four Steps

- Are Left Foot Accelerators Dangerous?

1,229 Views
  • share this:
  • Email to a Friend
  • Digg It!
  • StumbleUpon
  • Fark
  • Facebook
  • del.icio.us
  • Reddit
  • NewsVine

Your comment may take up to 15 minutes to appear.

Some HTML is allowed in the comments. See the list.
  • Wheelchair/car hit-and-runs: Who???s to blame? | BeautyAbility wrote on Dec 14, 2009 at 12:37 PM
    Pingback from Wheelchair/car hit-and-runs: Who???s to blame? | BeautyAbility
  • LeeDemp wrote on Dec 14, 2009 at 1:35 PM
    Thanks for posting this note. As a wheelchair user, I've almost been run-down on multiple occassions. I don't trust any vehicle to a pedestrian - Walking or Wheeling.
  • Abe Ternes wrote on Dec 14, 2009 at 2:35 PM
    I use a custom american flag that has an orange pole lower/shorter than doors and is easy to slide out of tube on chair when indoors or travel on transit/busses. I know its saved me many times since large trucks and 4X4/s can't see lower moving objects. Funny looks or Life? I enjoy both:)
  • Peter G. wrote on Dec 14, 2009 at 3:00 PM
    As a motorcyclist, I face the same problem on the road. Scientists who have studied this phenomenon call it "situational blindness". Drivers in cars are on the lookout for one thing: other cars. In this state of limited awareness, they'll ignore everything else - bicycles, pedestrians, wheelchair users, motorcycles, etc. There's only one solution for the out-of-the-ordinary travelers out there, unless they want to be victimized by a mindless drone: think and act like you're invisible - because to some people, you are!
  • Shawn wrote on Dec 16, 2009 at 9:22 PM
    It is a definite problem. I know of one person in a chair who was riding a transit bus got off the bus and was in front of it when the driver pulled out and ran over him, killing him instantly. The driver claimed not to have seen him. I have had several close calls while out and about in my wheelchair. I think that is a great idea you had Tiffiny about teaching to watch out for wheelchairs.How do we go about making it a national or international law?
  • Lil Fox wrote on Dec 17, 2009 at 7:44 PM
    I have only been in a chair for about 2 months and have been almost hit twice. The second time I got in trouble because the lady was so close in her Ford Expedition in the Walmart parking lot that I could reach out and touch it, so I did. I threw my fist into the side of her vehicle, unfortantely there was an officer walking out behind me. He chewed her but then chewed my rearend for hitting the car. I have done the same thing to people walking... had a kid walking and texting, I was moving pretty quickly in my chair but he never looked up... so I didn't either. :) Took him out at the knees. PAY ATTENTION!
  • Lil Fox wrote on Dec 17, 2009 at 7:45 PM
    I have only been in a chair for about 2 months and have been almost hit twice. The second time I got in trouble because the lady was so close in her Ford Expedition in the Walmart parking lot that I could reach out and touch it, so I did. I threw my fist into the side of her vehicle, unfortantely there was an officer walking out behind me. He chewed her but then chewed my rearend for hitting the car. I have done the same thing to people walking... had a kid walking and texting, I was moving pretty quickly in my chair but he never looked up... so I didn't either. :) Took him out at the knees. PAY ATTENTION!
  • Lil Fox wrote on Dec 17, 2009 at 7:46 PM
    I have only been in a chair for about 2 months and have been almost hit twice. The second time I got in trouble because the lady was so close in her Ford Expedition in the Walmart parking lot that I could reach out and touch it, so I did. I threw my fist into the side of her vehicle, unfortantely there was an officer walking out behind me. He chewed her but then chewed my rearend for hitting the car. I have done the same thing to people walking... had a kid walking and texting, I was moving pretty quickly in my chair but he never looked up... so I didn't either. :) Took him out at the knees. PAY ATTENTION!
  • Lil Fox wrote on Dec 17, 2009 at 7:46 PM
    I have only been in a chair for about 2 months and have been almost hit twice. The second time I got in trouble because the lady was so close in her Ford Expedition in the Walmart parking lot that I could reach out and touch it, so I did. I threw my fist into the side of her vehicle, unfortantely there was an officer walking out behind me. He chewed her but then chewed my rearend for hitting the car. I have done the same thing to people walking... had a kid walking and texting, I was moving pretty quickly in my chair but he never looked up... so I didn't either. :) Took him out at the knees. PAY ATTENTION!
  • Kimiki wrote on Dec 18, 2009 at 6:07 PM
    I'm glad you brought this up. I live in Canada, and this summer a simlilar accident happened in Fredericton, New Brunswick. It was a fatality. The woman (who was operating the wheelchair) died a day later in the hospital. As far as I know, the driver was never found or arrested. It made me really angry. Some people of course started questioning "Why was a woman in a wheelchair out at that hour?" ("that hour" being 11:30 at night... she was on her way back from a dinner party at a hotel - she was out of town and was here from Toronto on business). Sometimes the operator of the wheelchair could be to blame, but lets not forget that it's not always that easy to remain on the sidewalk. I don't know how many times I've been travelling on a sidewalk and when I get to the end of it, I can't get down (no ramp). So I have to turn around and If I want to have any chance at all at getting where I'm going, I have to find the nearest slope (being most often a driveway) so I can get to the other side. I work right downtown, and right there by my office there is a similar spot as I describe. I drive a car as well, so I more then understand how difficult it can be sometimes with people coming in all directions. So I am very very careful when I need to do this. But I can't tell you how many times drivers have wizzed right by me when I'm stopped at a corner, or even when I'm crossing and I have the pedestrian sign flashing (meaning MY TURN) and low and behold, the driver is on the phone. They could wheel you right over, when it's YOUR TURN, and they may not even notice they did. Some drivers are SO distracted. Just this week, I was coming out of my van and I was just pulling up my wheelchair ramp. A woman driver flew right by my van, driving on the WRONG side of the road and INTO my marking spot, missing wheeling right over my ramp by two seconds. She parked and I said "Hey! You were driving on the wrong side of the (parking lot) road and you nearly drove your car right over my ramp!". She laughed. Laughed. I said "oh yeah you think it's funny, it wouldn't have been. That ramp is more expensive then your car and YOUR INSURANCE would have paid for it". People are just NOT looking where they are going. And this time of year? Even worse. So look out for yourselves people, because they sure ain't!!!