Kara
Kara
Kentucky
Female
Married

Questions that cross boundaries

Posted: 8/18/2009 at 04:32 PM

  • share this:
  • Email to a Friend
  • Digg It!
  • StumbleUpon
  • Fark
  • Facebook
  • del.icio.us
  • Reddit
  • NewsVine

member(s) liked this post.

As the summer winds to a close, my fall schedule is bursting at the seams. In addition to writing and coordinating a few adapted sports programs in my area, I'll also be starting two new jobs as a group therapist and a college professor. I'll teach my first course in Abnormal Psychology next week. I'm over-the-top excited at the opportunity to introduce mental illness to a room of 25 students (who are exceptionally thirsty for knowledge I'm sure!) in a way that's dignified and non-stigmatizing.

I attended my adjunct professor orientation last night, met some other instructors, and learned about the school's policies. Everyone I met was friendly and sincerely  welcoming. It only made me more excited to work there. Just before leaving a packed conference room, a math professor tapped on my shoulder. I turned and he said, "Oh I wanted to ask, What's your disability?" He waited anxiously with a few other professors poised nearby obviously listening.

I paused for a second as I reeled through the probably hundreds of answers I've given over the years. Should I go with the always vague (a bone condition) or the more technical (it's a genetic mutation that causes a collagen disorder)? I've also told people that I have a form of dwarfism-which is entirely true. Most people, however, believe all little people walk (think TLC reality shows) so that doesn't usually extinguish their curiosity. In the end, I decided to tell this man the exact name of my diagnosis (Osteogenesis Imperfecta). I knew-and was correct-that he would have no idea what that meant. More so, he probably wouldn't even remember what I'd said to Google it at home. My answer initiated the response I expected-a confused nod, a smile, and he said, "Oh-I've never heard of that."

He also said, "I always ask."

And that left me with a question. REALLY!?

I wouldn't call my feelings about this angry, but I'm honestly baffled. I *think* people's intentions are to demonstrate that they are comfortable with my disability, but I'm utterly confused by the fact that a complete stranger would think it acceptable to ask such personal questions.

Do people who ask me the name of my disability also ask complete strangers:

Are you divorced?

How was your last pregnancy?

What's your sexual orientation?

What's your religion?

What race are your parents?

What's in your purse?

Of course not!

 

[Graphic caption: The figure of a person standing next to a large question mark.]

I understand that people usually mean no harm when they ask me what's the cause/name of my disability. They are as I've stated before "well-meanies". It's still a boundary that is not appropriate for strangers to cross. I have questioned myself as to why my reaction is defensive. I am not ashamed of my disability, but I have rather recently in my life accepted the reality that it's often misunderstood and can carry a great deal of stigma-especially associated with working (i.e. If she breaks easily, will she miss alot of work? Can she really travel from site to site? What if she breaks while on the job?).  Every disability carries some type of stigma. Mine carries a good bit of fear that sometimes leads to avoidance. My only request of the general public is to get to know a person before asking such a personal question. No matter how accepting one person may be of disability, stigma exists. If you're truly a supportive advocate, never expose people to a situation that could lead to discrimination.

How do you deal with this question?

More on Disaboom:

Attack of the well-meanies by me

Employment FAQ's by Kim Donahue

A discussion on Disclosing Disability in a Cover Letter

593 Views
  • share this:
  • Email to a Friend
  • Digg It!
  • StumbleUpon
  • Fark
  • Facebook
  • del.icio.us
  • Reddit
  • NewsVine

Your comment may take up to 15 minutes to appear.

Some HTML is allowed in the comments. See the list.
  • Mshores wrote on Aug 18, 2009 at 2:47 PM
    Those same well-meanies come at someone like me too, but because they can't see "the disability" then I have to be fat and lazy or a real slacker. Kara this is why we don't have those "Bruce Almighty" powers. Because we'd both start a clean up of the planet and teach some polite manners, smack some caring help up side of their heads and make real humans out of them.
  • Ruprecht wrote on Aug 18, 2009 at 2:52 PM
    Hmmmmmmm .... Well .... and I'm not reading this from an "in front of your face" situation, so it's not completely fair .... but you've admitted yourself, Kara, that you take a defensive stance in answering seemingly innocent questions. Some people try to strike up conversations out of curiosity / confusion / genuine concern / comfortability with the unknown. By you stating "he probably wouldn't even remember what I'd said to Google it at home", you assume - and possibly incorrectly - that he will forget. The fact of the matter is: You just don't know. Your's is a unique disability to many out there that you encounter. It is not a unique disability to you, however. You know it, you live it, you deal with it daily. While your thoughts and responses may be on the defensive, they could possibly convey different vibes to those who are asking - whether they be sincere in their requests or not. You have to be comfortable with your answer. You have control over your answer. You do not have control over what they hear (some people don't "hear" what you are "saying", I'm certain you know) and how they interpret your response. Best thing to do: Reveal what you feel comfortable with at the time of the asking without any preconceived notion of what's to come. By doing so, you just might be surprised at the follow-up. Be it positive or perplexing. Knowledge. It's a good thing to impart. Go well ............... Ruprecht / Michael
  • Kara wrote on Aug 18, 2009 at 2:55 PM
    You're exactly right @Mshores. People with less visible/invisible disabilities join me in this struggle. I was actually thinking on that while writing this...how that must feel like a heavy secret sometime to keep. Have you found it more or less beneficial to disclose in a situation like this?
  • Fledchen wrote on Aug 18, 2009 at 2:59 PM
    I think it depends a lot on context. I'm blind and I have a grab-bag of neurological quirks. I think it's ok for people to ask for basic information if I'm asking for an accommodation, as long as the information they're asking for is relevant to the accommodation. For example, I'll explain that I'm legally blind when I ask for materials to be provided in large print, or if I ask a store clerk to help me read a price tag. You'd be surprised how many people don't understand that "5 foot long white cane"="blind." I don't tell them what my specific vision impairments are because it's none of their business and they wouldn't understand it anyway. I think what I hate even more than invasive personal questions is unsolicited medical advice. No, Treatment X has nothing to do with my condition and won't fix it.
  • Kara wrote on Aug 18, 2009 at 2:59 PM
    Good points Ruprecht. I may very well be completely wrong in my assumption that he won't remember-I was more thinking of the complexity of the name of my diagnosis with this one though. It's a huge cumbersome word that (for me) it'd be tough to carry in my head for a couple hours. It is a nice reminder that we have control over the answer. I think though that's where I feel cornered sometimes though. I do have control but my options are limited. I feel like no matter how inappropriate the timing or place (a couple weeks ago I had someone come up to my table while sharing dinner with a friend), I don't REALLY feel like I have the option to point out that I feel like their question is inappropriate. If I did that, I am fairly certain (another assumption I know!) that it would only be assumed I'm a bitter person with a disability. So....I feel like my options are limited to those that include a smile and a nice educational response. That "control" doesn't always leave for much freedom.
  • Kara wrote on Aug 18, 2009 at 3:08 PM
    @Fledchen Medical advice frustrates me too. I can't count how many people have asked me if I've considered drinking more milk!? As if I wouldn't have given that a whirl a LONG time ago. I also don't mind providing basic information at all....it's when people want the details that I question whether our relationship grants them that level of information. It's almost always a case of where I know NOTHING about them but they want an intimate detail about me.
  • Kara wrote on Aug 18, 2009 at 3:09 PM
    @Fledchen Medical advice frustrates me too. I can't count how many people have asked me if I've considered drinking more milk!? As if I wouldn't have given that a whirl a LONG time ago. I also don't mind providing basic information at all....it's when people want the details that I question whether our relationship grants them that level of information. It's almost always a case of where I know NOTHING about them but they want an intimate detail about me.
  • Kara wrote on Aug 18, 2009 at 3:50 PM
    @Fledchen Medical advice frustrates me too. I can't count how many people have asked me if I've considered drinking more milk!? As if I wouldn't have given that a whirl a LONG time ago. I also don't mind providing basic information at all....it's when people want the details that I question whether our relationship grants them that level of information. It's almost always a case of where I know NOTHING about them but they want an intimate detail about me.
  • Liesl wrote on Aug 18, 2009 at 4:39 PM
    That is, indeed, a frustrating question. I got it the other day from the receptionist at a doctor's office, someone I assumed would know better.
  • Tania wrote on Aug 18, 2009 at 7:53 PM
    There are definitely some questions that I think cross the line. I have no problem answering the question about what disabilities I have. I consider it a teaching moment. However, questions about my personal life definitely are over the line. Also, questions about how my disabilities affect me in personal aspects of my life (especially sexually-related) are over the line. With such questions, unless you need to know, it's NOYB. Whenever I get questions about my disabilities, I give basic information that should give the person somewhat of an understanding of them. I also have different ways of explaining the disabilities, so that I can tell curious kids on a level they may understand.